Buying or Selling in Sheboygan County? Here’s What You Should Know — From Your Local Real Estate Agent

Hey there, Sheboygan County!

If you’re thinking about buying or selling a home in this beautiful part of Wisconsin, welcome! I’m Jonell Curtiss, a newly licensed real estate agent proudly serving Sheboygan County—from the heart of Sheboygan city to the scenic countryside of Elkhart Lake and everything in between.

Whether you're a first-time homebuyer, ready to sell, or just exploring your options, I’m here to guide you every step of the way with honest advice, local knowledge, and Midwestern dedication.

Why Sheboygan County?

Located right along Lake Michigan, Sheboygan County offers the best of both worlds: small-town charm and natural beauty with access to modern amenities and a growing housing market.

Here’s what makes the area special:

• 🏖 Stunning lakefront in Sheboygan, Oostburg & Cedar Grove

• 🚴 Outdoor adventures—kayaking, hiking, biking, and snowmobiling

• 🍽 Local eats—from fine dining in Elkhart Lake to food trucks in Plymouth

• 🛍 Unique boutiques, art scenes, and farmer’s markets

• 🏫 Excellent school districts & family-oriented communities

• 🏎 Home of Road America in Elkhart Lake and the Kohler experience

🏠 What’s the Real Estate Market Like in Sheboygan County?

As of Spring 2025, the Sheboygan County housing market is experiencing steady growth, with rising demand driven by buyers seeking space, value, and quality of life. Rural and lakeside areas, such as Elkhart Lake, are particularly attractive to buyers. Rocket - Help Everyone Home

Market Overview

• Median Home Values: The average home value in Sheboygan County reached $286,530 in February 2025, marking a 9.3% increase over the past year. Zillow+1Zillow+1

• Sales Activity: In February 2025, 79 homes were sold in Sheboygan County, a 43.6% increase compared to the previous year. Redfin

• Market Conditions: The county is characterized as a seller's market, indicating that demand exceeds supply. TMJ4 News+3Rocket - Help Everyone Home+3Rocket - Help Everyone Home+3

Rural and Lakeside Demand

Communities like Elkhart Lake are experiencing heightened interest, with the area maintaining a seller's market status. This suggests that homes in these regions are selling faster and at higher prices, reflecting strong buyer demand. Rocket - Help Everyone Home

🏘 A Quick Look at Popular Communities

Let’s break down some of the standout spots in Sheboygan County:

Sheboygan - Lively, lakefront living with shops, schools, and a downtown revival.

Plymouth - “The Cheese Capital of the World” — family-friendly with great parks, schools, and community vibes.

Sheboygan Falls - Historic charm, great neighborhoods, and just minutes from the city.

Elkhart Lake - Resort-style living, weekend getaways, and luxury lakefront homes.

Kohler - Known for upscale homes, private schools, golf courses, and the American Club lifestyle.

Oostburg & Cedar Grove - Tight-knit communities with a peaceful, rural feel and access to the lake.

Random Lake & Adell - Quiet country living with surprisingly quick access to the highway and nearby cities.

Download our free Sheboygan County Attraction Guide below.

Why Work With a New Agent?

You might wonder, “Why trust a new agent with such an important decision?”
The answer? I might be new to real estate, but I’m not new to dedication, hustle, or helping people feel at home.

Here's what I bring to the table:

✅ I’m focused and responsive—your priorities are my priorities
✅ I know the tools, trends, and tech that modern buyers & sellers expect
✅ I’m passionate about Sheboygan County and building long-term relationships
✅ I have local roots—and I’m ready to prove myself with real results

Let’s Talk Local Real Estate

Whether you're ready to buy, thinking about selling, or just curious about what your home is worth—I’d love to be your guide.

Let’s have a conversation. No pressure. Just honest advice from someone who genuinely cares about this community.

 jonell@thekramergroupwi.com
(920) 946-3184
www.thekramergroupwi.com

Thanks for reading—and welcome to the next chapter of your Sheboygan County story. I’d be honored to be part of it.

Subscribe and Stay Connected!

Don’t miss out on the latest real estate insights and updates for Sheboygan and Sheboygan County. Subscribe to The Kramer Group Blog today to get our newest posts delivered directly to your inbox!

Thank you for trusting The Kramer Group as your Sheboygan real estate experts. A higher form of real estate.

Written by: Jonell Curtiss
Real Estate Consultant

Download

Blog - Jonell Curtis - Buying or Selling in Sheboygan County - Side Banner 2